I'm pretty sure I know how this works but I just want to make sure. If Iron Legacy has Superhuman Redirection out (or is Advanced on his second side) and deals 5 damage to Nightmist, and she uses the Amulet of the Outer Gods to send it back to him, is it Redirected again?
Nope, unless he has multiple copies. He only redirects the first one, and each card can only redirect the same instance of damage once each.
Actually yes.
Ah, it does say first time, as does his advanced text (which I just looked at for the first time and edited my OP to mention as well). So I assume McBehrer is right in this one. Why do you disagree, TeslaRoyale?
If Iron Legacy is dealing damage to Nightmist, and she redirects it back, then he redirects the damage by Superhuman Redirection. There's no second time with Superhuman Redirection if the damage is coming from Iron Legacy to begin with.
Okay I have now managed to feel stupid twice in the space of six posts. Looks like everyone on this thread was right, and I was confused over nothing.
That wasn't the question, Tesla. The question was if IL was hit for 5, redirected it, and it got RE-redirected, would he redirect it again? And the answer is no.
No, actually the question was just if IL dealt the 5 and it was redirected, would he RE-redirect it? Sorry if I made that unclear.
Oh. Then yes, he would redirect it, as long as that's the first 5-damage hit he's taken that turn. I completely misread it; my apologies.